With a population of 236, Fishers Island is a must-see destination in New York State, United States. Consider staying at least one whole day in Fishers Island to see all of its attractions.
Although Fishers Island doesn’t have its own airport, you can fly to Tweed-New Haven (HVN), which is located 44 miles from Fishers Island.
Another option to get to Fishers Island is to pick up a car rental from New York, which is about 108 miles from Fishers Island. You’ll find branches of Sixt and Kyte, among others, in New York.
Expect to pay $3.90 per gallon in Fishers Island (average price from the past 30 days). Depending on the size of your rental car, filling up the tank will cost between $46.79 and $62.38.